I love this post from Chris Bowler. In the past 6-ish months, I've found myself in a similar mode. I've always wanted my task list to be digital. I've wanted it available on all of my various platforms synced through the cloud. For a while, I was an avid Things user. I've also experimented with Trello (I still use it as sort of a long term "issue tracker").
But late last year, when I discovered the Bullet Journal system, I decided to dive in. There's just something about picking up a pen and writing physically that connects with my brain more. I more like I know what I have to do, and I feel more accomplished when I can check something off.
I don't subscribe religiously to every little bit, but I think you have to find what works for you. I'd like to put more notes and events in to log myself. I've also been playing a bit with the Omnifocus 2 beta for keeping track of longer term tasks. But for managing my day to day, having a pen and a notebook has been fantastic.